Why Your Best Is Never Good Enough

Now I have had many great guests on the podcast before but the podcast episode with Dr Bhrett McCabe was one of the most eye-opening podcasts I have ever recorded. He said so many things that were so applicable to us all, to every single one of us, regardless of what stage of life we are in.

“We want success all the time, a part of us deep down wants success because we have to have it in order to feel valued by ourselves.”- Bhrett McCabe

Bhrett is not a runner, in fact, when introducing himself, he said he could barely believe he was on a running podcast, THAT is how little he was associated with running.

However, as with so many things, each aspect of our lives parallel the internal struggles we are going through, and I hope todays post can make you think a little differently about how you treat yourself. Remember what Evie said about being kind to yourself, yeah, that kinda talk.

Even though I might not be running right now, so much of what Bhrett said resonated with me, particularly what he said about comparison.

One of the reasons we feel inadequate when we compare ourselves to others is because we never compare ourselves to areas we have strengths. 

In the same way, we don’t compare ourselves to the improvements we have made to be better, about steps we have taken, instead we hone in on our weaknesses and areas we feel we have failed.

As the article in People Magazine headlined (yes, THE People Magazine featured me!!!!!), I am intentionally gaining weight, and that is the primary reason I still have not run.

When I stopped running, I did need a break, who knows how long that would have lasted, but the reality is, that now, at this point, I probably would be back running, I would like to get back into a few light easy runs a week, but it has become almost a battle of will now.

That might sound ridiculous, but I want my first run back to be one of celebration, one to signify the next stage of my running life, and one that is just for the sheer joy of it, not for the reward on the other side.

I don’t want to run until my cycle comes back. I want to know that I am doing everything I can to reassure my body it is safe, and even though one individual run would not sabotage that, it is the principle.

That being said, I am not going to lie to you, it has been really hard at times to see my body in the mirror and feel fear, wonder if I will ever be fit again, or will I continue to put on weight, year after year, until one day, I wake up, and I am unable to walk up the stairs.

They say it sneaks up on your after all.

I know that is irrational, and I am learning more each day that your size really doesn’t define you. You are who you ARE, not what you look like, or what you do.

My family, friends, and the people who care about me, treat me the same way they did a year ago, two years, ago ten years ago. They love what is inside.

Your friends and family love that light that shines bright in you when you are confident and happy. Whatever you need to do to be happy, is what is going to make them love you more, not being a certain body size or image.

When I look back on photos of  myself now, from just before the London Marathon, I almost wince.

Even at that moment, I thought I was still bigger than most runners I competed against. I was thin, but they were skinny. I was normal, they were underweight.

Now I can step back, I can see that actually, I was just as thin as those other girls, I just couldn’t see it.

I am not saying there is anything wrong with being lean. If you are going to try to be one of the best in the world, to give yourself the best chance, you have to run a lot, eat the right foods, and get your body ready to perform. Which is exactly what I was doing.

Naturally, your body will become lean, in prime position to run to your potential, and I don’t think I was doing any damage to my long-term health. I was doing it in a healthy way. Just not a sustainable body shape for me to maintain.

I have to say, as I look back at my body, I see that I was edging on too thin, certainly too thin for my personal genetics to maintain, and I am not sure it was healthy to be there other than for that small 6 week window where I was accomplishing my lifetime running goals.

I wouldn’t go back and change it, though. I did what I needed to do to be the best I could be, and it paid off, big time!

I am not sure I would have reached that goal if I hadn’t trained as hard as I had and eaten all the right foods for performance. But, just as Lanni Marchant and I talked about taking time off, and gaining back much more weight than you have lost, it still wasn’t where my body was comfortable being.

Now I am away from that, I can see how skewed my perception was. How distorted my body image of myself was.

I saw lean runners all around me, which led me to believe that it was normal, I was just normal. My fear was if I gained weight, I would immediately jump from normal (my version of it), to obese. There was nothing in between.

I was scared. I was attached to my identity as a professional runner, and I didn’t want to lose that. I thrived on the respect that gave me.

My family and friends tried to tell me that, but at the time, I just shrugged it off. Once again, in my mind, I was bigger than most of the other girls I competed against. I was, but only when you compare to the girls who have taken a lean body image too far, and are struggling with eating disorders.

Still a dangerously close line for me to walk.

What is crazy is that even in that moment, when I was in the best fitness I had been in, I still wasn’t confident. I still would go to the bathroom some days and look at my body in the mirror. I knew I looked fit, and I knew I was lean, but I still couldn’t feel satisfied with the way I looked. I still wasn’t as toned as the other girls I raced against.

I think that is what I am really trying to say here, in that long and rambly way of telling you that we are never happy with how we look, never 100% confident, which is ridiculous, because once again, I believe each and every one of us has something special to offer this world, and it is NOT our bodies.

Sure, if you are good at a sport, your body is the part that does help you to achieve something great, BUT you need the personality to go with it, you know that old quote, “given time, hard work beats talent”, well, it’s true. You could be the most talented person in the world, but if you did not have the motivation and dedication to train, you will end up getting beat. It is the person they are INSIDE that means we can accomplish those big goals.

When I compare to that Tina, the lean Tina I was there, and it is tough not to feel like I have “let myself go”, feel that I am huge, feel that I am just soft and jiggly. Thankfully I have my new goal to focus on, and that keeps me in the right mindset that I am doing the right thing, but it still isn’t easy sometimes. I still feel like I might end up losing respect and the approval of others.

I try to remind myself, and hopefully remind you that:

It is who we ARE that really makes us be our best, not what we look like or what we do.

Sure, being healthy and having your body be fit enough to do the things you love is a big part of your confidence, but just keep in mind that even if you did reach your dream weight, the body size you think is absolutely perfect, you will NOT be happy, you will still feel like you could do more.

We never reach that perfection, so striving for it will only bring you more frustration and guilt.

I am saying this because I have been there, and believe it or not, I actually feel a lot more comfortable in everything about who I am and what I look like now, than I did during that marathon phase.

I always had that paranoia that I wasn’t good enough, I wasn’t doing enough, but in reality I was, I was doing the best I can. Rather than celebrating that and being proud of that, I felt guilty that I wasn’t doing enough.

Now I am learning to just learn to be. Be relentlessly who I am, no matter what.

So that is what I am doing.

It’s not always easy, I don’t always feel like I am doing the right thing, but bringing it back full circle, Dr Bhrett McCabe said:

“We cannot be content in life, we simply can’t, because if we are content, we would never grow, and if we never grow, we stop getting new experiences, and having new, valuable learnings.”- Bhrett McCabe

I LOVE that, and what a good way to think about things. We are constantly growing, and so there is nothing wrong with those moments of doubt in who we are, those are the moments that make us figure out a new way to grow.

This one was also pretty powerful, and so true.

“People who have a growth mindset, believe that they are constantly a work in progress, and that is a very powerful and successful mindset to have. Everything I do, is not a determinant of who I am, everything I do is an opportunity to build who I am.”- Bhrett McCabe

There were so many more of those in that episode, please, go listen to it, trust me, you will not regret it!!

In other news

The #NoWatchMe movement of running by feel is starting to get some momentum, as more runners are trusting me to run using effort rather than pace. Steve and I spent some time on the Effort Scale PDF this weekend to make it even easier to understand how to run your best without looking at your watch.

If you haven’t yet tried it, please give it a try, and let me know how you get on.

For those of you who downloaded this PDF before, this one is much more detailed and clear, so I would recommend downloading again. I also made it black and white, so you don’t have to use 3 ink cartridges to print it 😉

What are you guilty of comparing yourself to?

Think we could be friends?

I am always this honest, real, raw. If this article speaks to you, I really believe we could be friends and I could help you with what you are working through. Drop your email below, and I will reach out to you

Powered by ConvertKit
body image, confidence

Related Posts


  • oh I ADORE that phrase about us wanting success in order to feel VALUED BY OURSELVES.
    I think too often we (the outsider) think for others it is about wanting to feel valued by society.

  • I will absolutely be listening! I love how he said we’re comparing our weaknesses to other people’s strengths – so true! I’ve backed off a lot on comparisons but there’s always more work to be done. Great post today lady 🙂 xoxo

  • The point about comparison to other people’s strengths–so true. And we always do it in our weakest moments!

  • I love reading everything you are saying on this topic! You are so brave and I just know your comeback will be amazing!

  • I think it’s tough when you’re surrounded by people all aiming for the same tough goals, all putting their bodies through tough training…it normalises it. But in the greater population it ISN’T normal or, arguably, entirely healthy. Yes it might be necessary to reach those goals but in terms of living a healthy “normal” life, it’s fairly extreme. I respect you for saying you don’t regret it, but I respect you even more for what you’re now doing.

  • TINA YOU ARE AMAZING! Your posts have been so inspiring, educational, and emotional. I cannot believe how wise you are, how much you have matured, and how FEARLESS you are! So beautiful inside and out! XOXO

  • Kathleen McAuliffe
    May 8, 2017 11:32 am

    In true NoWatchMe style, I wish I could print this post out and tape it over the face of my Garmin! You’ve stayed so strong through the easy and hard moments, and when your future babies read this, they’ll know just how much you committed to them ! Best wishes

  • Peg DeBiasi
    May 8, 2017 12:49 pm

    One of my favorite quotes, that applies to all of life: “Comparison is the thief of joy” – Theodore Roosevelt. I keep it on my computer desktop as a reminder.

  • This is my favorite podcast by far! The comparison point is so relevant in all areas of our lives. Bhrett provided a wonderful reminder that what I do is about growth for me, not everyone else. I am in a pretty competitive running group, one that is always measuring performance and where breaks are implied as weaknesses. However, no one has exactly my schedule, my body, my life struggles, or my unique combination of strengths. What I love about Bhrett’s discussion the most is to take what makes me particularly ME and celebrate my strengths. Some days it is my dedication: long day at work and still get out there, or my ability to use vision to see my self endure when feeling fatigue. These are not measurable but felt and utilized. Such a powerful message!!!

Comments are closed.